This isn't a red or blue problem. It's a red, white and blue problem.
“It is better that ten guilty persons escape, than that one innocent suffer.”Sir William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England, 1769
A model act from the Justice Restoration Foundation
Accountability for deliberate misconduct. Protection for honest prosecutors.
Today, a prosecutor who knowingly hides evidence or uses false testimony can almost never be held to account. PAPTA creates a narrow remedy for deliberate misconduct, protects the good-faith judgment of the prosecutors who do the job right, makes DOJ's own grand jury rules binding, and limits asset freezes before trial.
The founders' standard
Protecting the innocent came first. It still should.
That it is better 100 guilty persons should escape than that one innocent person should suffer, is a maxim that has been long and generally approved.Benjamin Franklin, letter to Benjamin Vaughan, 1785
It's of more importance to community, that innocence should be protected, than it is, that guilt should be punished.John Adams, defending the British soldiers at the Boston Massacre trial, 1770
I consider [trial by jury] as the only anchor ever yet imagined by man, by which a government can be held to the principles of its constitution.Thomas Jefferson, letter to Thomas Paine, 1789Why it matters: PAPTA's grand jury title tells jurors the decision to indict is theirs alone.
If men were angels, no government would be necessary. … You must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself.James Madison, Federalist No. 51, 1788Why it matters: PAPTA is how government controls itself, with independent oversight of its own prosecutors.
From inside the Justice Department
“The prosecutor has more control over life, liberty, and reputation than any other person in America.”
“The citizen's safety lies in the prosecutor who tempers zeal with human kindness, who seeks truth and not victims, who serves the law and not factional purposes, and who approaches his task with humility.”
Robert H. Jackson, Attorney General of the United States, address to the nation's U.S. Attorneys, April 1, 1940
PAPTA is written for the prosecutor Jackson described. It protects the ones who seek truth, and holds to account the rare few who seek victims.
Transparency at every stage
Bring the interview room and the grand jury into the light.
The moments that decide a federal case happen out of sight: witness interviews, the decision to charge, the grand jury. DOJ's own manual already promises some transparency at each step, and says none of it can be enforced. PAPTA would make it law.
Every interview recorded
Every interview of a witness, target or potential cooperator, including proffer sessions, recorded from start to finish, preserved with a backup, and produced to the defense. Today DOJ's recording policy covers custodial interviews only.
Notice before charges
In white-collar cases, written notice to a target before charges, a chance to submit a statement or meet with prosecutors, self-surrender instead of arrest, and notice when target status ends.
A voice at the grand jury
A target may ask to testify or submit a written statement and evidence. A refusal must be in writing, and the grand jury is told the target asked.
The whole story to the grand jury
A binding duty to present substantial evidence that directly negates guilt, and a bar on evidence obtained through a clear constitutional violation. Courts can't enforce DOJ's own policy after United States v. Williams (1992).
Grand jurors who know their power
Jurors are told they are independent, that the decision to indict is theirs alone, and that they can ask for evidence that may show innocence. After indictment, the defense gets the prosecutor's instructions and relevant testimony.
Deals and offers on paper
Every plea offer in writing and on the record, a written record of every benefit promised to a cooperator, and all evidence of innocence disclosed before a guilty plea.
Transparency runs to the person charged, in their own case, and to the public only in aggregate data. Nothing here opens grand jury files during an investigation or names anyone who wasn't charged. Every provision above is in the October 2026 discussion draft. See every provision, stage by stage.
Property and due process
Your property shouldn't be gone before the verdict.
Before any plea or verdict, the government can freeze or seize property, sometimes far beyond what is tied to the alleged offense. A business can fail, and a family can lose the means to pay for a defense, long before any finding of guilt.
Title III of the discussion draft. It is written to stand alone, so it can move with PAPTA or as its own bill.
Only what's tied to the offense
Pretrial restraint limited to property traceable to the alleged offense, capped at the alleged loss in fraud cases, and never substitute assets.
Money for a defense, a home and a payroll
Untainted funds released for counsel of choice, living expenses and a business's payroll, taxes and rent, with a prompt hearing and no sale of property before a verdict.
Returned, with interest
Property returned within 30 days of an acquittal or dismissal, with interest, and public reporting by district of what was seized, forfeited and returned.
The problem
The rules exist. Nobody can enforce them.
Since Imbler v. Pachtman (1976), prosecutors have had absolute immunity from civil suits for their courtroom work, even when the misconduct is deliberate. Professional discipline is rare and slow.
The Justice Department's own manual tells prosecutors to notify targets before indictment, to present substantial evidence of innocence to the grand jury, and to consider a target's request to testify. Those are policies, not rights. No one charged with a crime can enforce them.
DOJ's own watchdog sees the strain. Misconduct complaints to the office that reviews DOJ attorneys rose about 54% in two years, to 2,081 in FY2026, handled by an office with 18 full-time positions. The Inspector General warns the Department "faces risk in its oversight capacity." Read the report.
The fix
Narrow on purpose.
- A civil remedy for 13 specific, knowing acts, such as fabricating evidence or hiding evidence of innocence.
- Honest mistakes and negligence are never actionable. Charging, plea and sentencing decisions stay protected.
- An acquittal or reversal alone proves nothing.
- Independent review inside the DOJ Inspector General, with due process before any finding.
- Recorded witness interviews, notice before charges in white-collar cases, and binding grand jury rules.
- When misconduct is proven, related cases get a second look.
Innocent until proven guilty should mean something. So should the rules prosecutors already promise to follow.
We don't ask you to believe any one person is innocent. We ask whether the process can tell the difference.
For families
The punishment shouldn't start before the trial. PAPTA puts honesty back at the front of the process.
For business owners and professionals
Physicians, executives and owners lose licenses and livelihoods long before any verdict. Deliberate abuse should carry a cost.
For honest prosecutors
Clear lines protect the people who follow them. PAPTA shields good-faith judgment and screens weak complaints early.
Bipartisan by design
Due process doesn't belong to one party. This isn't a red or blue problem, it's a red, white and blue problem. PAPTA is written for lawmakers who believe in limited government, civil liberties, or both.